Trademark Classes: All for One OR One for All

Quick Overview

• Quick Answer: The number of trademark classes you select depends on your current and future business needs.
• Quick Overview: Deciding whether to file under one trademark class or multiple can be tricky. This article breaks down what trademark classes are, why they matter, and whether you should keep it simple or cover all your bases.

Common Questions & Answers

1. What is a trademark class?
   Trademark classes categorize goods and services to simplify legal protection. There are 45 classes in total—34 for products and 11 for services.

2. Why are trademark classes important?
   Your trademark is protected only in the classes you choose, so they directly impact your business's scope of protection.

3. What happens if I choose the wrong class?
   You risk losing protection in your actual industry, potentially leading to legal disputes or re-filing fees.

4. Can I add classes to my trademark later?
   No. If you need protection in additional classes, you must file a new application.

5. Is it better to select more classes upfront?
   Not always—it depends on your budget and long-term business goals.

Step-by-Step Guide to Trademark Class Selection

1. Identify your current offerings.
   Make a list of the goods/services your business offers and match them to their respective trademark classes.

2. Consider your future plans.
   If you plan to expand into new markets, add those potential classes upfront.

3. Check your budget.
   Trademark fees increase with each class, so balance protection with affordability.

4. Research potential overlaps.
   Ensure you’re not infringing on existing trademarks in your chosen classes.

5. Consult a trademark attorney.
   They’ll help ensure your application is comprehensive and aligned with your goals.

Historical Context

Trademark classes have been around since the Nice Agreement of 1957, when global governments decided to create a standardized classification system for intellectual property. The system makes it easier for businesses to secure protection across borders. Without it, filing trademarks internationally would feel like solving a Rubik’s Cube blindfolded.

In the U.S., the USPTO adopted this system to simplify application processes and prevent conflicts. However, with great simplicity comes great responsibility: applicants must carefully select classes that represent their brand’s current and future offerings.

Business Competition Examples

1. Apple Inc.
   Apple trademarks cover multiple classes, including technology (Class 9), software (Class 42), and even retail (Class 35). This ensures they’re protected across all areas of their business.

2. Nike
   Nike files under classes for footwear (Class 25), retail services (Class 35), and sports equipment (Class 28). They strategically protect their brand across their entire product lineup.

3. Starbucks
   Starbucks covers classes for beverages (Class 32), cafes (Class 43), and branded merchandise (Class 21), safeguarding their coffee empire.

4. Etsy Sellers
   Many small businesses start with just one class to protect their niche products but often file additional applications as they grow.

Discussion

The decision to file under one or multiple trademark classes is often a tug-of-war between cost and coverage. For startups or businesses operating on a tight budget, filing for a single class can feel like a no-brainer. It keeps costs down and focuses your protection on your core products or services. If your current operations are well-defined and unlikely to expand in the near future, this approach makes sense.

However, businesses with an eye on broader coverage—especially those anticipating growth into new markets—might opt for multiple classes. Filing for additional classes upfront ensures you’re protected not just for what you offer now but for future products and services, too. For instance, a company selling clothing might eventually want to expand into footwear, accessories, or retail services. Filing these additional classes in the initial application prevents future legal headaches.

Here’s where it gets tricky: you cannot add new classes to an existing trademark application once it’s filed. If you need protection in more classes later, you’ll have to file a brand-new trademark application for those classes. This means you’re essentially starting the process over—from fees to waiting for approval—which can double your costs and time investment.

So how do you strike the right balance? Consider these three factors:

1. Budget: Filing for multiple classes is more expensive upfront, as government fees are charged per class. Add in attorney fees (if applicable), and the cost multiplies quickly. If funds are limited, focus on the classes that are critical to your current business operations.
2. Business Goals: Think beyond today. If you have concrete plans to expand into new markets, the extra upfront cost of filing multiple classes is often worth it.
3. Risk Tolerance: Filing only one class now might leave you vulnerable to competitors who could register similar marks in adjacent classes. If your industry is highly competitive, broader protection might be a better investment.

For example, imagine starting a brand that sells organic skincare products. Filing only under Class 3 (cosmetics and skincare) may cover you now, but what if you later decide to sell branded towels or spa equipment? Filing for those additional classes in the future will mean starting over and possibly contending with competitors who may have already claimed those classes.

Ultimately, the decision comes down to how much you’re willing to invest today to save potential costs and headaches tomorrow. If you’re unsure, consulting a trademark attorney can help you align your trademark strategy with your long-term goals.

The Debate

• One-Class Advocates

  • Argument: Lower costs and simpler filing process. Perfect for small businesses with limited offerings.
  • Counterpoint: Risks under-protection if the business grows into other industries.

• Multi-Class Enthusiasts

  • Argument: Future-proofs your trademark and makes it harder for competitors to imitate your brand.
  • Counterpoint: Higher costs upfront, even for classes you might never use.

Takeaways

1. Trademark classes determine the scope of your legal protection.
2. Filing for one class saves money but limits your coverage.
3. Filing for multiple classes offers broader protection but costs more.
4. Think about your business’s future plans before deciding.
5. Consulting a trademark expert can help you make the best choice.

Potential Business Hazards

1. Overpaying: Filing unnecessary classes increases costs without added value.
2. Under-protection: Selecting too few classes leaves your business vulnerable.
3. Future re-filing: Missing relevant classes now means reapplying later, doubling costs.
4. Legal disputes: Incorrect class selection can result in trademark challenges or revocation.

Myths and Misconceptions

1. Myth: More classes always mean better protection.
   Fact: Extra classes are only valuable if they align with your business.
2. Myth: Trademarks automatically cover all industries.
   Fact: Your protection is limited to the classes you choose.
3. Myth: Adding classes later is easy.
   Fact: Once filed, you must submit a new application for additional classes.

Book & Podcast Recommendations

1. “Building a StoryBrand” by Donald Miller
   A great read to help align your trademark choices with your brand’s story.

2. “The Business of Intellectual Property” Podcast
   Features expert advice on trademark strategies.

3. “Trademarks for Dummies” by Amanda Michaels
   A beginner-friendly guide to trademark law.

4. “How I Built This” Podcast
   Stories of brand building that highlight the importance of IP protection.

Legal Cases

1. Apple Corps v. Apple Computer

   • Summary: A dispute over trademarks between a music company and a tech company.
   • Relevance: Highlights the importance of choosing the right classes to avoid conflicts.

2. Victoria’s Secret v. Victor’s Little Secret

   • Summary: A trademark dilution case involving class overlap.
   • Relevance: Shows the risks of vague or incomplete class protection.

3. Monster Energy v. Beastly Energy

   • Summary: A trademark infringement case in overlapping classes.
   • Relevance: Demonstrates the need for comprehensive filing.

Share Your Expertise

Explore more about trademarks, patents, and IP strategy at Inventive Unicorn.

Wrap Up

Deciding how many trademark classes to file is a balancing act between cost and protection. Start with what you need, but always keep an eye on future growth. A well-chosen trademark strategy can safeguard your brand for years to come.