💬 Four Things Patent Examiners Don’t Need to Hear

💬 Four Things Patent Examiners Don’t Need to Hear

You’ve got a patent examiner on the phone. Your company just tripled sales. Customers love the product. You built the first prototype in your garage, and the company behind the patent cited against you went out of business years ago.

Then the examiner asks, “Which part of claim one are we discussing?”

That’s where I’d start. In my experience, founders often spend their best minutes on facts that explain why the business matters. A patent examiner interview gives you a chance to accomplish something more specific. You can find out exactly how the examiner reads your claim, where they see the feature in the cited prior art, and whether a supported amendment would address the rejection.


⚡ Quick Summary

  • Sales figures need a connection to the invention you claimed. Commercial success can support nonobviousness when the evidence shows why customers bought the claimed invention.
  • Keep the garage story short. Bring the technical detail you learned during development if it helps explain the claim or the prior art.
  • Translate customer impact into claim language. If buyers love a safety feature, find the language that requires the mechanism behind it.
  • Read the competitor’s patent even if the company closed. A qualifying published disclosure can still be prior art.
  • Use the call to improve the written response. Take an agenda, identify the real disagreement, and keep the Office action deadline on your calendar.

âť“ Common Questions and Answers

What is a patent examiner interview?
It’s a discussion with the USPTO examiner handling your application. You can use it to clarify how the examiner interprets a claim, discuss the cited references, or get feedback on a proposed amendment.

Which documents should I bring?
Bring the Office action, current claims, relevant pages and drawings from the cited references, and any proposed claim language. If you plan to discuss an amendment, mark where the original application supports it.

Can strong sales help overcome a rejection?
They can support an argument against obviousness when the evidence connects commercial success to the claimed invention. Sales evidence cannot cure a novelty rejection if one qualifying reference already discloses the full claim.

Can I add a feature we developed after filing?
First check what your application disclosed as originally filed. A feature omitted from the current claims may still have support in the original description, claims, or drawings. A later improvement that lacks that support may call for a separate filing strategy.

Do I still have to file a written response after the interview?
Yes, if the Office action requires one. Use the interview to shape the written response and calendar the reply deadline.


🛠️ How to Prepare for the Interview

  1. Identify the rejection and claims at issue. Check whether the examiner is raising novelty, obviousness, or another issue. Match your question to the stated reason for rejection.
  2. Underline the disputed claim language. Find the exact feature, sequence, or relationship you want to discuss.
  3. Read the cited passage in context. Open the complete drawing or surrounding paragraphs. Determine what the reference actually teaches and how the examiner applies it.
  4. Prepare one question about the gap. For example, “Where does this reference show the latch engaging before the motor starts?”
  5. Bring one supported amendment if it makes sense. Mark the original disclosure that supports the wording. Check whether the proposed scope would still cover what matters to the business.
  6. Record the result and prepare the written reply. Confirm what the examiner understood or agreed to, identify what still needs work, and reflect the substance of the discussion in the application record as required.

🕰️ How Patent Examination Got Here

The U.S. patent system gives inventors an opportunity to obtain time-limited rights in exchange for disclosing their inventions. A patent application describes the invention, and its claims define the scope of the protection the applicant seeks. That structure explains why a two-line claim limitation can matter more in an interview than a full product demo.

The Patent Act of 1952 expressly set out nonobviousness as a requirement. Patent examination could therefore ask both whether the invention was already disclosed and whether the differences from what was known would have been obvious to someone skilled in the field.

In Graham v. John Deere Co., the Supreme Court explained how courts should analyze obviousness. The inquiry includes the prior art, differences between it and the claims, and the level of ordinary skill. Evidence such as commercial success or a long-felt need can also inform the analysis.

Decades later, KSR International Co. v. Teleflex Inc. emphasized that obviousness calls for a flexible analysis. Known components arranged in a predictable way may support an obviousness rejection. For a founder preparing for an interview, it pays to ask what the proposed combination would actually do and what reason the examiner gives for making it.

Modern examination uses both oral discussion and a written record. An interview gives the applicant and examiner room to test a reading of the claim, walk through a drawing, or discuss alternate language. The written record preserves the substance of the discussion and the arguments or amendments the applicant asks the USPTO to consider.


🏪 Three Examples From Competitive Markets

A best-selling hitch accessory. A startup attributes rising sales to a self-centering mechanism that engages after coupling. If the claim covers that mechanism and buyer records show customers specifically chose the product for it, commercial evidence may strengthen a nonobviousness argument. If the sales spike coincides with a major discount and the data show little about buyer preferences, start with the mechanical differences the claim requires.

A pump that customers swear by. Buyers say a pump prevents costly overflows. The original filing shows a two-sensor setup, but the pending claim refers broadly to a sensor and a controller. The interview could explore whether adding the original two-sensor arrangement would distinguish the cited design and leave the company with commercially useful coverage.

A storage-rack maker that closed years ago. The examiner cites its published patent for a locking rail. The new company’s strongest question is whether that patent shows a locking rail that engages in the sequence its claim requires. The old company’s closure tells you something about the market. Read the drawings to learn what the company disclosed.


🔍 Four Talking Points That Can Derail the Call

1. “We sold more than everyone else.” I’d celebrate that with the team. Before bringing it to the examiner, I’d ask how the business measured success and what drove it. A sales chart can show a spike. It usually takes more evidence to explain why the line went up.

The connection between commercial success and the claimed invention is sometimes called a nexus. If customers bought the device because of a claimed mechanism, records showing that preference can help. If they bought because of the brand, a discount, better distribution, or a popular accessory outside the claim, those facts affect what the sales evidence can establish.

2. “Let me tell you how I came up with it.” The garage story can make a terrific About page. For the call, pull out the moment you solved the technical problem. If your design lets a bracket rotate while the base stays fixed, start with the motion and the claim language that requires it.

3. “Our customers say this changes everything.” A customer may explain why a feature matters. The claim tells you whether the application seeks protection for that feature. If your device prevents a motor from starting until a latch is engaged, walk through that sequence instead of reading a five-star review aloud.

A common complication is that the feature customers rave about appeared in the newest prototype. Pull up the original filing and check for support before proposing any amendment. If the description already shows the mechanism, discuss how you might claim it. If the mechanism was developed later and lacks original support, consider how to protect it separately.

4. “The company behind that patent went out of business.” A company can shut down and still leave behind a published disclosure the examiner can use as prior art. Check whether the reference qualifies against your claim, then read what it actually teaches. The date on a closing announcement rarely answers either question.

The type of rejection changes what you ask. For a novelty rejection, ask where one qualifying reference discloses every required part of the claim as arranged. For an obviousness rejection, look at the examiner’s full reasoning, including why someone skilled in the field would have made the proposed change and whether the resulting design has the claimed features.

You can use the same preparation for the written response. Put the claim wording next to the cited paragraph or drawing and explain the precise disagreement. If the parties disagree about what a phrase means, address that interpretation directly. If you agree on the meaning and disagree about what the reference shows, focus on the reference.


⚖️ The Debate Over Bringing Business Evidence

Side One

Keep a first interview focused on the claims and the rejection.

Patent examiner interviews are easier to use when everyone has the same claim and drawing open. A founder can spend several minutes explaining the market and still leave the examiner unsure which element is disputed.

For many rejections, the fastest way forward is to identify one practical difference. If claim one requires a sensor upstream of a valve and the cited drawing shows it downstream, both sides can discuss the same problem immediately.

A narrow agenda also helps you find out whether an amendment is necessary. The disagreement may turn on how a phrase is read. If you can resolve that question, you may be able to respond without giving up commercially important claim scope.

This approach also makes it easier to follow up in writing. You leave with the claim language, the examiner’s interpretation, and a concrete issue to address. The investor deck can stay open in its own tab.

Side Two

Bring business evidence when it helps explain why the claimed invention was nonobvious.

Some technical improvements appear simple with the benefit of hindsight. Evidence that a problem persisted despite earlier attempts, or that buyers adopted a solution because it solved that problem, can add context to an obviousness analysis.

Commercial evidence is strongest when it lets the examiner connect the market outcome to something the claim requires. Purchasing criteria that expressly call for the claimed feature can tell a clearer story than a company-wide revenue chart.

Customer evidence can also help identify the issue worth discussing. If buyers consistently credit a particular mechanism, compare that feedback with the claims and the original disclosure. The result may support an evidence-based argument or point toward a commercially meaningful amendment.

Use the interview to discuss where the evidence fits. When the response relies on that evidence, put it into the written record in an appropriate form so the examiner can consider it.


âś… Key Takeaways

  • Open the interview with a disputed claim phrase and the exact passage the examiner cites.
  • Check which rejection you’re addressing before deciding what evidence or argument to use.
  • Keep the connection between commercial results and the claimed invention clear.
  • Verify original support before discussing an amendment.
  • Use the interview to prepare the written response and watch the filing deadline.

đźš§ Business Risks During a Patent Response

Narrowing past the product you actually sell. A proposed amendment may address the reference and also exclude the production model or a competitor’s likely workaround. Compare the wording against the product and variations that matter before committing to it.

Assuming the latest prototype is covered by the original filing. Engineering teams keep improving products while applications are pending. Check which version the original description and drawings support. If an important improvement came later, review filing options and any disclosure dates that may affect them.

Confusing patentability with freedom to operate. An expired patent can be relevant prior art. The question of whether someone else can stop you from selling depends on potentially enforceable rights that cover your product. Check the relevant patents and their status for that separate analysis.

Using a sales chart without checking the product mix. A revenue line that combines several products may tell the examiner very little about the claimed invention. Figure out which version sold, what feature customers chose, and what else drove sales.

Letting the interview crowd out the deadline. Calendar the written response independently of the call. If an interview happens close to the deadline, leave enough time to review and file the reply.


đź§Ż Myths and Misconceptions

Myth: “Customers love the product, so the USPTO should grant the patent.”
Customer enthusiasm helps explain demand. To use it in an obviousness argument, gather evidence that links it to the claimed invention. To answer a novelty rejection, address what the single cited reference discloses.

Myth: “An expired patent can’t be used against my application.”
Expiration concerns the patent’s term. The published disclosure can still qualify as prior art, so check its relevant dates and what it teaches.

Myth: “I can describe my latest upgrade during the interview and add it to the pending claims.”
Any proposed claim amendment needs support in the application as filed. Showing a new prototype during the interview cannot supply missing original disclosure.

Myth: “Once the examiner agrees on the call, I’m done.”
Use the agreement to prepare the formal response or confirm the next procedural step. An interview does not replace a written reply required by the Office action.


📚 Books and Podcasts

  • Patent It Yourself, by David Pressman and David E. Blau. A practical introduction to patent applications, searching, and examination.
  • Patent Pending in 24 Hours, by Richard Stim and David Pressman. A resource on provisional applications and the importance of documenting an invention at filing.
  • IPWatchdog Unleashed, hosted by Gene Quinn. Conversations about patent practice, policy, and the business decisions behind IP protection.

⚖️ Three Cases Worth Knowing

Graham v. John Deere Co. The Supreme Court explained the framework for obviousness and identified evidence such as commercial success and long-felt need as potentially relevant. For an interview, this gives business evidence a specific role in the analysis.

KSR International Co. v. Teleflex Inc. The Supreme Court applied a flexible approach to obviousness and explained why combining familiar elements in predictable ways may be obvious. When an examiner proposes a combination, examine both the reason for making it and what the resulting design would do.

Fox Factory, Inc. v. SRAM, LLC. The Federal Circuit examined the link between patent claims and evidence involving a commercial bicycle chainring. The case illustrates why important product features outside the claims can affect whether that connection is presumed and why evidence tying results to the claimed invention matters.


🤝 Talk Through Your Office Action

If you’ve received a patent rejection, bring the Office action, your current claims, and the reference that concerns you most. If there’s a feature you think the examiner missed, mark it in the claim and find where the original application describes it.

At Miller IP Law, we can review what the examiner is relying on, discuss whether an interview would help, and evaluate whether to argue the existing claim language or propose an amendment. If the distinction comes from a later product version, we can also discuss filing options for that improvement. Learn more at lawwithmiller.com.

To chat about this one-on-one, grab a free consult at strategymeeting.com


🎯 Before You Get on the Call

Find the exact phrase in your claim that you believe the prior art misses. Open the page or drawing the examiner cites for it. Write one question that asks how the reference shows that specific feature or arrangement. A good answer to that question can give you a clear starting point for the written response.

← Older Post

Beyond the Prototype | A Startup’s Path to Patents

RSS
🛠️ Can You Patent an Improvement to an Existing Product?

Can you patent an improvement to an existing product? Often, yes—if the improvement is new, useful, and non-obvious over the prior art. This article explains...

Read more
📄 Can You File a Patent Reply Behind Your Lawyer’s Back?

You spotted a mistake in your patent office action and already have a lawyer. Can you file a reply yourself? Devin Miller explains why an...

Read more